Trade Republic vs eToro: Broker Comparison

Well known in its home country of Germany, Trade Republic is a 100% mobile app that is starting to break into the French market with its exclusive, innovative offering. eToro, for its part, is an international multi-asset trading platform and a leader in social trading. Which of the two should you choose? Find out in this Trade Republic vs eToro comparison.

Key Information

To start this Trade Republic vs eToro comparison, let’s look at the key information about these two brokers.

  • Trade Republic is a neobroker: a new player focused on simplicity that aims to shake things up by bringing a number of innovations to online trading. Launched in Germany in 2019, it recently decided to extend its offering to France. In its home country it operates as a brokerage bank, while in France it is considered an investment firm. Either way, it is supervised by BaFin, the German financial supervisory authority, and the Bundesbank, Germany’s central bank. For now, its services are only available in Europe. To date, the international fintech has a few hundred thousand clients, mostly in Germany and Austria. It aims to attract more than 100,000 users in France by the end of 2025.
  • eToro is a Cypriot broker. Launched in 2007, it offers its services in more than 140 countries, including France. It is a highly regulated broker, as its subsidiaries are supervised by several financial authorities, including CySEC, the FCA, ASIC and the FSAS. Its clients have access to more than 2,000 financial instruments. It also has more than 1,000 employees and claims around 20,000,000 users worldwide. eToro has very good reviews, as our eToro review page shows.

On related topics, our articles “AxiTrader vs Pepperstone” and “Trading 212 vs eToro” are a useful complement to this comparison.

eToro vs Trade Republic: Awards

The awards received by these two brokers are among the points we examined in this Trade Republic vs eToro head-to-head:

  • Trade Republic is a very recent broker. Nevertheless, it has already won the title of best bank in Germany for trading, awarded by the leading business daily Handelsblatt.
  • eToro has also received several awards, particularly for its trading platform.

Security Measures at Both Brokers

Comparing the security measures put in place by these two brokers in this Trade Republic vs eToro head-to-head, we noted that they have adopted broadly the same measures to protect their users’ funds, in line with the regulations in force in Europe:

  • Both are regulated brokers operating entirely legally, and several financial authorities monitor them closely.
  • Both brokers hold their users’ deposits in accounts segregated from their own. At Trade Republic in particular, each user’s account is opened with the German bank solarisBank AG in a pooled account.
  • For its retail clients in Europe trading leveraged products, eToro offers negative balance protection.
  • If eToro becomes insolvent, free insurance covers its clients up to €1 million,
  • At Trade Republic, client funds are protected up to €100,000 by the German deposit guarantee fund. This protection does not apply to securities held in the brokerage account. However, these are not lent out but held by HSBC, the neobroker’s custodian bank.

Available Assets: Trade Republic vs eToro

The assets available to trade vary from broker to broker. This Trade Republic vs eToro comparison let us compare what each offers:

  • Trade Republic clients can invest in nearly 8,500 stocks and ETFs, in France and around the world. They can also opt for an automatic, regular savings plan covering nearly 3,500 stocks and ETFs. European, French, Asian and US stocks are available, including Google, Apple and BNP Paribas. For ETFs and trackers, traders have access to products such as MSCI USA Energy, Amundi MSCI India and Xtrackers MSCI Mexico. The neobroker also offers more than 40,000 factor certificates and knock-out products, as well as indices, bonds and commodities.
  • Traders on the eToro platform have access to around 2,000 financial instruments, including more than 2,000 stocks, 16 cryptocurrencies, 49 currency pairs, 13 stock indices, 6 commodities and 249 ETFs.

Trading with eToro vs Trade Republic in November

The trading offerings themselves differ enormously from one broker to the other. Here are some key points we noted in this Trade Republic vs eToro head-to-head:

  • Unlike eToro, Trade Republic does not offer leverage, so its clients cannot use it. At the Cypriot broker, retail traders have access to maximum leverage of 1:30, while professionals get up to 1:400.
  • Trade Republic is the only broker offering traders in France a free automatic investment plan in ETFs and stocks.

Deposits and Withdrawals

We also compared deposits and withdrawals in this Trade Republic vs eToro comparison.

  • At Trade Republic, users don’t have much choice of deposit and withdrawal methods: the fintech only accepts bank transfers to fund the trading account. eToro offers several payment methods, including the most common ones such as bank cards and transfers, as well as other methods such as PayPal, Skrill and Neteller.
  • The time it takes for funds to reach the account depends on the deposit method chosen. Since Trade Republic only accepts bank transfers, traders have to wait one to two business days before the deposit is credited to their account, and the same applies to withdrawals. At eToro, funds can be credited instantly depending on the deposit method used.
  • Both brokers only accept one account currency: Trade Republic has opted for the euro and its competitor for USD. eToro traders can deposit in other currencies such as EUR, GBP, PLN and CZK, but the broker then charges fees for converting to USD.
  • The German neobroker does, however, have an advantage over the Cypriot broker in that it requires no minimum deposit.

Fees

These two brokers have opted for two completely different pricing models. We noted several points in this Trade Republic vs eToro head-to-head:

  • The German fintech charges no spreads or order commissions. It only applies a third-party fee of €1 per transaction, whatever the asset and the trading venue. It charges no custody fees and no transfer fees. The cash account is also free to manage and transfer, as are stock dividend payments and ETF distribution or accumulation. However, some services are charged, such as placing orders by post, transfers by letter, registering for general meetings and registering registered shares,
  • Unlike its competitor, eToro charges spreads and swaps. While deposits and account opening, closure and management are free, this broker charges withdrawal fees, conversion fees and inactivity fees.
Tableau originalDiversifiez votre patrimoineInvestissez dans l’artDes tableaux originaux, pièces uniques signées par l’artiste. Un actif tangible, loin des écrans et des cotations.Voir les tableaux →

Trading Accounts

In this Trade Republic vs eToro comparison, we compared the trading accounts offered by these two brokers:

  • Trade Republic remains true to its policy of simplicity: it offers just one type of account, a brokerage account for private use only, which lets users trade all available assets.
  • eToro offers a free demo account with $100,000 in virtual money to learn trading and get used to the tools, charts, features and platforms. The Cypriot broker also offers an Islamic account for Muslim traders. Unlike its German competitor, it also has a professional account. For retail clients, eToro offers a standard account.

Trading Platforms

Trading platforms are among the criteria for choosing a broker. In this Trade Republic vs eToro comparison, we compared what each offers:

  • True to its goal of simplicity, the neobroker Trade Republic has chosen to be available only on mobile. Users therefore cannot trade from a computer or on the web. Some traders may find this convenient, but it can be a handicap for those used to developing customised strategies.
  • eToro, the leading social trading broker, offers its own trading app and platform, allowing users to trade around 2,000 financial assets. They stand out for their ease of use and include several features that have made the broker famous, such as CopyPortfolios and CopyTrader.

Trading Tools

Traders often need to use various tools. In this Trade Republic vs eToro head-to-head, we noted that the two brokers work differently in this respect:

  • While most brokers give traders access to several useful tools, the fintech Trade Republic does not offer any for now.
  • The Cypriot broker provides its users with several tools, including technical indicators, market analysis, news, an economic calendar and a currency converter. eToro also offers innovative social trading features.

Education

Before entering the world of trading, beginners need training. The same goes for seasoned and intermediate traders looking to improve. Training offerings and educational resources are therefore among the criteria for choosing a broker. According to our comparison in this Trade Republic vs eToro head-to-head, the two brokers are not on an equal footing when it comes to education:

  • Trade Republic has no educational resources at all. Its users have no access to a demo account, teaching tools or even guides.
  • eToro has one of the most comprehensive programmes. First, users have access to a demo account to learn, test and get familiar with the platform, tools and features. Second, they have ebooks, video tutorials, guides, courses and webinars to support their learning. However, this broker’s educational content is aimed mainly at beginner traders.

Customer Support

We analysed the customer service of these two brokers in this Trade Republic vs eToro head-to-head:

  • eToro traders have the advantage of being able to contact advisers directly and quickly by phone and live chat, available Monday to Friday. At Trade Republic, the phone is reserved for complaints. To contact advisers, traders must fill in an online form or send an email.
  • Both brokers’ websites have been translated into several languages, including French.
  • Both brokers’ customer support is also multilingual.

Trade Republic vs eToro: Pros and Cons

These two brokers have chosen two completely different models, and each has its strengths and weaknesses. Here are some we identified in this Trade Republic vs eToro comparison:

  • Trade Republic is one of the newest brokers. Despite its young age, this neobroker aims to bring several innovative ideas to help its users invest their savings better. The fintech relies on simplicity and low fees to attract investors. Nevertheless, many users complain that its customer support is hard to reach. The lack of an education programme and trading tools could also be a serious drawback.
  • eToro is a heavily regulated player whose reliability is beyond doubt. Not only is it popular in the market, it is also a benchmark for copy trading. It suits both beginners and more experienced traders. Despite the wide range of financial instruments available on its platform, its fees remain high.

Our Verdict

At the end of this Trade Republic vs eToro comparison, here is our verdict:

  • Trade Republic is aimed more at users who want to trade only from their phone. Although very well known in its home country, it is only just starting to make its mark in the French market. Despite its innovative ideas, traders used to working with tools will find it hard to use its services.
  • eToro needs no introduction among traders. While its offering tends to suit beginner traders, it also caters to those looking to do social trading.

To compare these brokers further, you can also widen the comparison to eToro vs Trade Republic vs Scalable Capital, or eToro vs Capital.com.

Suivez-nous sur Telegram