Short selling is an investment strategy that lets you profit by betting on a fall in the price of a stock or other asset. In this article, we explain how to short a stock, how short selling works and what rules to follow to make it profitable.
What Is Short Selling? Definition
Short selling is an investment strategy that involves borrowing a stock in order to sell it. The stock is then bought back to be returned to its original owner. Short selling is used when you want to bet on a fall in the price of a stock or another asset, because it lets you buy it back at a lower price than you sold it for and pocket the difference.
Short selling is also known as:
- Short sell
- Shorting
- Short position
- Selling short
Short selling is not necessarily a complicated strategy and can be used by both experienced traders and beginner investors who trade. However, the risk-reward ratio of short selling remains significant.
On related topics, our articles “The best broker for trading” and “Trading sites for beginners” are a useful complement to this guide.
How to Short a Stock
- Open a trading account – First, you need to choose an online broker that allows short selling on its assets. This is the case with DEGIRO, which also offers low brokerage fees.
- Fund your account – Next, deposit the capital you want to devote to stock market investing into the account you opened.
- Find stocks to short – Then look for stocks you expect to fall in price and that you can short.
- Open a short position – You can then open a position automatically, borrowing the chosen stocks and securities from your broker by placing a sell order.
As explained in trading for beginners, if you expect an asset to lose value, you can make money on the stock market during downturns by opening short positions with derivatives.
How Short Selling Works
The Principle of Short Selling
Short selling is a trading method whose aim is to sell an asset you do not own at the time of the sale by borrowing it.
More precisely, a short seller proceeds as follows to sell an asset short:
- The first step is to borrow the asset you want to short from your broker
- You then sell the asset, hoping its price will fall.
- You buy the asset back when its price reaches a lower level.
- You return the asset to the broker you borrowed it from, making a profit equal to the difference between the sale price and the purchase price.
In short, short selling means betting on a fall in an asset’s price and making money from that decline, which explains why investors are drawn to this strategy during crises or recessions.
Short selling should not be confused with forward selling, which only concerns derivatives, futures and options, whereas short selling only concerns the cash market.
Key Features of Short Selling
Short Selling to Speculate on a Falling Asset
First of all, shorting an asset really means betting that its price will fall over the short or longer term.
So if the investor’s forecast is wrong and the asset’s price rises, they will have to buy it back at a higher price and will make a loss.
That is why short selling on the stock market is most often done with short-term positions and is a speculative strategy.
Short Selling as a Hedging Strategy
Some investors also use short selling to hedge a long position. This is known as a hedging strategy.
Short selling can be used to lock in gains made on a long position by reducing potential losses without having to exit the long position.
Short selling can therefore help you protect certain positions in the market without being used to make profits on a purely speculative basis. The aim here is above all to protect your gains and reduce your losses on an investment in the same asset. But it is essential to take into account the fairly high costs of this method.
Short Selling and Margin Trading
To short sell, you need a margin account, which lets you borrow money from your broker using your capital as collateral.
As with long margin trading, losses from short selling can be unlimited, within the framework of the 25% minimum maintenance requirement.
If the amount available in your trading account falls, the broker may issue a margin call and ask you to deposit more capital, or your position may be closed automatically.
Short Selling Costs to Consider
Of course, short selling a stock or another asset involves higher costs than a standard purchase. In addition to the usual transaction fees, the short seller must pay interest on the shares borrowed from the broker.
The Right Conditions for Short Selling
You should not short an asset at just any time or under any conditions. Apart from a hedging strategy, it is essential to expect the chosen asset’s price to fall. Such price declines occur in different situations, including:
- A stock market crash – When the stock market crashes, most listed assets fall sharply.
- Disappointing results – For a stock, when the listed company publishes annual or quarterly results well below expectations or forecasts, this often causes the price to fall.
- A scandal or damaging news – Negative news, a scandal or a major affair that harms the company or its brand image can also send its share price tumbling.
As you will have gathered, before shorting a stock you need to keep up with market news and news about the issuing company.
Who Is Short Selling For?
Although any investor can short sell without necessarily having extensive knowledge of trading strategies, this method does require certain skills and is better suited to investors with a particular profile. Here are the prerequisites before you start:
- A good understanding of analysis – Being able to carry out sound fundamental and technical analysis is essential for shorting an asset.
- Good knowledge of the market and the asset being sold – You also need to understand what can influence the price of the asset you are following and want to short.
- Knowing when to short – Short selling also requires quick reactions and making your decision at the right time, neither too early nor too late, to avoid significant losses.
Short Selling Example
Let’s take a simple example of short selling for speculative purposes, that is, to make a profit:
- Imagine you expect a stock trading at $50 to fall over the next three months.
- You borrow 100 shares from your broker and sell them to another trader. You are now “short” 100 shares, since you have put on the market an asset you do not own and have borrowed.
- A few days later, the company that issued the stock publishes results below expectations, and the market reacts with the price falling to $40.
- You decide to close your short position and buy 100 shares at that price to return the shares you borrowed.
- Your profit, excluding margin account interest, is $1,000, or $10 per share.
The Best Brokers for Short Selling
Diversifiez votre patrimoineInvestissez dans l’artDes tableaux originaux, pièces uniques signées par l’artiste. Un actif tangible, loin des écrans et des cotations.Voir les tableaux →Which Assets Can You Short?
Short selling is a strategy you can use with various investment instruments, including:
- Cash equities – Short selling lets you take positions on ordinary shares without actually owning them, at a slightly higher cost. You can do this through a broker such as DEGIRO.
- Stock CFDs – With stock CFDs, you can short sell without first borrowing the shares as you would on the cash market. The cost is lower here, and you can use these CFDs with the broker Vantage.
- The SRD – The SRD (Deferred Settlement Service) lets you speculate with 1:5 leverage on forward contracts and therefore short stocks. It is available for many shares offered by DEGIRO.
As for the assets themselves, stocks are not the only ones that can be sold short. You can also short:
- Stocks – You can short many stocks such as Air France, Tesla, Atos, Biophytis, Casino, CGG, Europcar Mobility, Eutelsat, Genfit, Novacyt, Renault, Solocal, Solutions 30, Unibail or URW and Vallourec, among many others.
- Cryptocurrencies – Through CFDs, you can also short the main cryptocurrencies such as Bitcoin, Ethereum, Dogecoin and other tokens.
- Stock market indices – Again with CFDs, you can short a stock market index such as the CAC 40, the Dow Jones, the SBF 120 or the Nasdaq.
- Forex – The foreign exchange market also lets you speculate on falling exchange rates for currency pairs such as EUR/USD, EUR/GBP, USD/JPY or GBP/USD.
- ETFs – You can also short an ETF, an investment fund that replicates the behaviour and performance of a stock market index.
- Commodities – Again through CFD trading, you can take short positions on commodities such as gold, oil or coffee.
- Bonds – Finally, short selling can also apply to a bond, a security issued by an institution such as a government that is essentially a loan.
Can You Get Rich With Short Selling?
Before you start short selling through online trading, you probably want to know whether it is really possible to make money with this strategy. The answer is of course yes, because short selling stocks can make you as much money as buying them.
- Financial markets are governed by the law of supply and demand and, in this case, one person’s loss is another’s gain.
- A financial market is a zero-sum game in the sense that the profits made by traders are in fact the losses recorded by other investors. With short selling, you can therefore make money by betting on negative events, and thus on market declines and corrections.
- So if one trader makes money by opening a short position, another trader loses money because they held a long position on the same stock.
- Finally, stock markets move in cycles. This means they go through successive bull and bear phases, giving short sellers the chance to seize opportunities during downturns.
When to Short a Stock: The Best Times for Short Selling
Short selling can be profitable, but you still need to know when to use this strategy. As we saw above, you short sell when a company is at the centre of a scandal or dispute, when it publishes disappointing results, or during a stock market crash or financial crisis.
Of course, speculating on a stock market crash is not always possible because, fortunately, these events are still relatively rare. But you can easily and regularly spot disappointing announcements on certain stocks that may cause their price to fall.
In any case, the best times to short sell are when conditions are difficult. That is why short selling is a controversial practice regulated by various bodies, including the AMF, and it can be banned outright during a major financial crisis.
Why Short Sell?
Short selling is a valuable strategy for many investors. There are many reasons to short stocks or other securities, and here are the main ones:
- More profit opportunities – First, short selling gives you more opportunities to make money, since it lets you speculate even when stock markets and their stocks fall.
- Protecting and hedging long positions – Traders who hold their assets for the long term also like to short stocks, taking short positions opposite to their main positions to hedge against losses from a downward correction without having to sell their long positions.
- Enhancing your strategies – Finally, short selling is also valued for being stimulating and particularly interesting, which is why it is often used alongside other traditional investment strategies.
Short Selling – Advantages
- Short selling lets you make profits at any time, even when prices are falling and during financial crises
- The short selling strategy can be applied to almost every asset on the market, not just stocks
- On CFDs or forex, short selling lets you use leverage to maximise your gains.
- It is a relatively simple strategy that is accessible to everyone, beginner and experienced traders alike.
- Finally, this strategy is interesting from a strategic point of view and notably lets you hedge your open positions.
Short Selling – Disadvantages and Risks
- Like any other trading strategy, short selling carries the risk of price and market manipulation.
- Finally, as fees are relatively higher, short selling can turn out to be a losing strategy and cause significant losses to your capital.
Short Selling – AMF Rules
In France, short selling is regulated by the AMF (Autorité des Marchés Financiers). The conditions set by this authority are as follows:
- Any individual or legal entity wishing to take a net short position equal to or greater than 0.2% of the share capital of a listed company whose shares are admitted to trading on a European market has one trading day to report this transaction to the competent authorities.
- If the reported net short position is 0.5% or more of the share capital, the authority reviewing it must make it public.
- Each time a position crosses a 0.1% threshold, up or down, a reporting obligation also applies.
- Finally, the AMF strictly prohibits buying sovereign CDS (credit default swaps) that are not used to hedge a directly correlated exposure.
So if you want to open a short position on the stock market, you must follow these rules to the letter. Short selling activities are closely monitored because their speculative nature can be dangerous for a market or a company. These regulations notably help prevent movements like those seen in GameStop shares, which triggered a crisis in the least liquid stocks.
But be careful! These regulations mainly concern short selling of listed stocks, and more specifically investments made by institutions and professionals, given the large sums needed to reach these thresholds. If you speculate on the downside with CFDs, these rules do not apply, as with other derivatives, whatever the amount of capital and gains involved.
Tips for Short Selling Successfully
Short selling is an interesting activity and investment strategy in many respects, but it is also a risky method that should be approached with caution and by following certain rules. Here are some tips to help you put it into practice in the best conditions.
- Get trained – The first rule is of course to learn before you start using this strategy. Most brokers offer training, learning materials, tutorials and personalised support.
- Practise and test your strategies – Another simple tip is to practise, for example by opening a demo account with a reputable broker. You can then test short selling risk-free by practising placing orders with virtual capital.
- Carry out analysis – The success of any trading strategy depends on each investor’s ability to carry out technical analysis to assess the strength of a downtrend or anticipate a bearish reversal in an asset.
- Keep an eye on the news – A downward correction is often caused by major news or a negative announcement about a listed company, or even the publication of its results. You therefore need to follow market news to spot the announcements that will cause the most volatility.
- Use stop orders – You also need to be able to cut potential losses at the right time or take your profits in time. To do this, after defining your strategy and goals, you can place a stop or limit order on your position.
- Be cautious – Finally, caution is essential if you decide to short a stock, since you risk larger losses than with a standard position. Be especially careful before using leverage, and stick to low leverage if you are a beginner.
Short Selling – Our View on This Strategy
Our view of short selling remains broadly favourable. Short selling has already proven itself in the past and remains a worthwhile investment strategy in many respects. But it may suit some traders and not others, as opinions on this method vary widely.
- Of course, short selling appeals to investors who want to seize every market opportunity by taking profits even when their asset’s price falls, whatever the market situation.
- Short selling should also be part of your hedging strategies if you are a long-term investor, as it lets you offset your losses while keeping your long positions open.
- However, some market specialists criticise short selling, arguing that it encourages various forms of financial manipulation. For example, ill-intentioned people may spread rumours about a company to trigger a fall in its share price and then profit from that fall by taking a short position.
Our view, as trading and market specialists, is that short selling remains an attractive strategy if everyone follows the rules, which is now usually the case thanks to regulation by bodies such as the AMF. Done properly, short selling can deliver attractive profits.
Conclusion – Should You Short Sell, and Is It Profitable?
Ultimately, is it worth speculating on stocks and other markets through short selling? Our conclusion is that this strategy remains advantageous when markets are falling, but that it is of course risky for the investor’s capital if they do not use stop-loss orders.
With the help of a good broker such as DEGIRO, which offers low brokerage fees, or a broker like Vantage, short selling can let the most conscientious traders benefit from opening short positions on many assets.
So feel free to open your investor account now to try it out.
Want to try short selling but not sure which broker to use for your stock market orders? Ask us for advice by leaving a comment!
Are you a short seller who wants to share your tips and analysis with other investors? Leave us a comment to tell us about your experience.
